Skip to main

Best Pizza in Valley Cottage

Crispy, Fresh, and Always Made to Order – Every Time!

Welcome to The Pie Man 🍕

Welcome to The Pie Man 🍕
The Pie Man isn't just a pizza spot—it's a local favorite in Valley Cottage, NY. If you're craving a classic, no-fuss, thin-crust pizza made fresh daily, you're in the right place. Our cozy family restaurant and bar serve up Italian comfort food that keeps customers coming back. Whether you're dining in, picking up, or getting delivery, we make ordering easy and convenient.

Thin, Crispy, and Packed with Flavor

Thin, Crispy, and Packed with Flavor
Thin-crust pizza done right—crispy, flavourful, and always fresh. We take pizza seriously, using simple, high-quality ingredients baked to perfection. But there’s more to love! Our menu features hot, hearty sandwiches and fresh salads, ensuring something for everyone. Whether it’s a quick lunch, family dinner, or late-night bite, every dish is made fresh daily for the best flavours in every bite. Classics or new favourites—we’ve got you covered.
Explore Our Menu
Dine Your Way – In, Out, or at Home!

Dine Your Way – In, Out, or at Home!

Relax and enjoy—dine in our cosy indoor space or savour your meal on our inviting outdoor patio, perfect for any occasion. Whether it’s date night, a group gathering, or a solo bite, we’ve got the right vibe. No time to stay? We’ve got you covered with fast, easy pickup and delivery. Just place your order, and we’ll handle the rest, bringing great food straight to you.
Order Now

Food That Looks as Good as It Tastes!

Every dish we serve is fresh, hot, and made to order. Take a look at our signature thin-crust pizzas, hearty sandwiches, and inviting dining space. Whether you’re here for a quick bite or a full meal, the experience is just as great as the food.

Catering for Your Special Events

Catering for Your Special Events
Planning a party or event? We offer catering services to bring the same fresh flavours to your gathering. Whether it’s a birthday, office lunch, or family get-together, we’ll handle the food so you can enjoy the moment. Give us a call at 845-268-8789 to set up your catering order.
View Our Catering Menu

A Cozy Spot for Family & Friends

A Cozy Spot for Family & Friends
Enjoy a warm, casual dining experience at The Pie Man—a local favorite for families, friends, and tourists alike. Savor our delicious homemade pies and hearty meals in a welcoming atmosphere perfect for catching up and making memories. Whether you're a regular or visiting for the first time, you'll feel right at home with our friendly service and comforting flavors.

Come Visit Us!

We’re open every day of the week, ready to serve you fresh and delicious food. Hours: Monday - Thursday: 11 AM - 10 PM Friday - Saturday: 11 AM - 12 AM Sunday: 11 AM - 10 PM Come by, grab a slice, and see why locals and visitors love The Pie Man. We can’t wait to serve you!

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Very, very good thin-crust pizza. I'm from Northern Wisconsin, where the pizza is top-notch, so I wasn't expecting much from an East Coast pizza place, but this pizza was excellent. My girlfriend got some Chipotle lime wings, which were also delicious! I'll definitely be back!

Adam V.

Adam V.

If Google allowed 10 stars, I would give it. The pizza was amazing. You can tell the ingredients are fresh. I have been back multiple times. I can’t say good enough things about the food and staff.

Erica M.

Erica M.

High-quality bar pies with high-quality ingredients. The pizza here will not disappoint. We had transitional cheese, margarita, sausage with pickled peppers, and a new-style dough. Everything was out quick and tasted amazing. I’ll absolutely keep coming back!

Anthony C.

Anthony C.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Dine In

Catering

Outdoor Seating

Serves Great Cocktails

Earn Rewards with Every Bite!

Earn Rewards with Every Bite!

Love our pizza? Get rewarded for it! Join our loyalty program and earn points every time you order. Use your points for discounts, exclusive deals, and special offers. It’s our way of saying thank you for being a valued customer. Signing up is quick, and rewards add up fast!

Frequently asked questions

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

We are located in Valley Cottage, NY at 107 NY-303

Our location