Passion for Pizza, Commitment to Freshness
Our team believes in simple, high-quality ingredients and making every order fresh. Whether you're dining in, picking up, or getting delivery, we make sure every bite is as good as the last.
The Beginning of Something Special
The Pie Man started with a simple idea: great pizza made the right way. Co-owners Austen Araneo, Travis Koester, and Tyrone Azanedo always believed that food brings people together, and they wanted to create a place where everyone could enjoy a delicious meal in a welcoming setting. With years of experience and a deep love for Italian flavors, they opened The Pie Man in Valley Cottage, NY, with one goal—to serve thin-crust pizza that keeps people coming back.
A Commitment to Quality
From the start, we knew that quality would set us apart. Every pizza we serve is made with the finest ingredients, from hand-stretched dough to fresh toppings that bring out bold, rich flavors. Our thin crust is what makes us different—it’s crisp, light, and perfectly balanced with every bite. We don’t believe in shortcuts. That’s why everything is prepared fresh daily, so when you order from us, you know you’re getting the best.
What Makes Us Different
At The Pie Man, we do things the right way. Our team prepares everything fresh daily, making sure every order meets our high standards. With an estimated health score of 95 out of 100, we take pride in serving food that is not only delicious but also made with care. Whether you’re dining in, picking up, or getting delivery, you can always count on us to make it a great experience.
A Place for Everyone
Located at 107 NY-303 in Valley Cottage, NY, The Pie Man is a spot where locals, college students, and visitors all feel welcome. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite, grabbing food to go, or settling in for a meal with friends, we’re here to make it easy and enjoyable.