Skip to main
The Pieman Pizza
  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Pizza
  • Sandwiches
  • Salads
  • Pasta & Entrees
  • Kids
  • Desserts
  • Sauces & Dips
  • Drinks

The Pieman Pizza Menu

107 NY-303, Valley Cottage, NY

107 NY-303, Valley Cottage, NY

·

  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Pizza
  • Sandwiches
  • Salads
  • Pasta & Entrees
  • Kids
  • Desserts
  • Sauces & Dips
  • Drinks

Most ordered

  • Build Your Own Pizza.

    Build Your Own Pizza

    $13.00+

  • Margherita 16".

    Margherita 16"

    $23.00+

  • Wings.

    Wings

    $14.00

  • Chopped Caesar.

    Chopped Caesar

    $12.00

  • Garlic Knots.

    Garlic Knots

    $8.00

  • Sliders.

    Sliders

    $15.00

  • Popcorn Chicken.

    Popcorn Chicken

    $14.00

  • Fried Calamari.

    Fried Calamari

    $14.00


Appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks

Housemade mozzarella sticks served w/ vodka sauce.

$13.00

Mozzarella Sticks.

Wings

$14.00

Wings.

Popcorn Chicken

Deep fried chunks of chicken. Served w/ GoHo sauce (Gochujang Honey)

$14.00

Popcorn Chicken.

Garlic Knots

Our thin crust pizza dough tied into bowties, deep fried & tossed in garlic butter. Served w/ a pepperoni sauce.

$8.00

Garlic Knots.

Meatballs

3 Housemade Meatballs served w/ Marinara.

$11.00

Meatballs.

Fried Calamari

$14.00

Fried Calamari.

Sliders

Three sliders of your choice, each served with a pickle. Choose cheddar burgers, Maple Brown Sugar Nashville hot fried chicken, or chicken parm.

$15.00

Sliders.

Vodka Riceballs (3)

$13.00

Onion Rings

Housemade beer battered onion rings served w/ horsey sauce

$8.00


Pizza

Margherita 16"

16" pizza with fresh mozzarella and fresh basil over your choice of house marinara, vodka or fra diavolo sauce.

$23.00+

Margherita 16".

Build Your Own Pizza

$13.00+

Build Your Own Pizza.

Meat Lovers 16"

16" pizza loaded with housemade meatballs, bacon, pepperoni and DPNB sausage.

$26.00

Buffalo Chicken 16"

$21.00

California Ranch 16"

16" pizza with chicken cutlet, bacon, cheddar, avocado crema and chipotle ranch.

$23.00

Korean White Hot 16"

16" white pizza topped with fried chicken tossed in GoHo sauce (gochujang hot honey), ricotta, our house cheese blend and scallions.

$23.00

Sausage & Spicy Peppers 16"

16" pizza with housemade spicy pickled peppers and heritage pork sausage from Nyack's DPNB Pasta & Provisions.

$23.00

Salty G.O.A.T. 16"

A special blended spread of Ricotta, Goat Cheese & Honey. Topped w/ Arugula, Prosciutto, Shaved Red Onion & Drizzle of Balsamic Reduction

$23.00

Veggie Supreme 16"

16" pizza with spinach, mushrooms, roasted red peppers, white onions and artichoke.

$21.00

Drunken Popeye 16"

$23.00

Chopped Garden Pie 16"

$21.00

Austen's Delight 16"

$22.00


Sandwiches

Chicken Balsamico

Seasoned grilled chicken with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, arugula and balsamic reduction on ciabatta.

$17.00

Chicken Balsamico.

Parm Sandwich

Your choice of chicken cutlet, eggplant or housemade meatballs with marinara and melted house cheese blend on ciabatta.

$19.00+

Parm Sandwich.

Veggie Vibe

$16.00

Veggie Vibe.

Smash Burger

$16.00

Pesto Chicken

$18.00


Salads

Chopped Caesar

Chopped romaine tossed in our housemade Caesar dressing with croutons and shaved parmesan.

$12.00

Chopped Caesar.

Garden Salad

Mixed Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Carrots, Shaved Red Onion & Housemade Italian Dressing

$10.00

Garden Salad.

Italian Chopped Salad

Iceberg Lettuce, Roasted Red Peppers, Shaved Red Onion, Pepperoni, Prosciutto & Housemade Italian Dressing

$15.00

Italian Chopped Salad.

Baby Spinach Salad

Baby Spinach, Dried Cranberries, Granny Smith Apples, Housemade Candied Pecans, Crumbled Goat Cheese & Creamy Balsamic Dressing

$14.00

Baby Spinach Salad.

Pasta & Entrees

Parmigiana

Your choice of thin Italian-seasoned chicken cutlet, fried eggplant or housemade meatballs smothered in our housemade sauce and melted house cheese blend, served over spaghetti.

$21.00

Parmigiana.

Penne Vodka

Penne tossed in our housemade creamy vodka sauce, garnished with grated parmesan and fresh basil.

$16.00

Penne Vodka.

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$19.00

Spaghetti & Meatballs.

Pesto Pasta Caprese

$18.00

Spicy Bolognese

$21.00


Kids

Kids Buttered Penne

$7.00

Kids Chicken Tenders

$10.00

Kids Sliders

Mini sliders sized just right for kids.

$8.00

Kids Spaghetti & Meatballs

$10.00


Desserts

CinnaKnots

$9.00


Sauces & Dips

Add a side of our housemade sauces and dips.

Blue Cheese

$2.00

Chipotle Ranch

$3.00

Honey Mustard

$2.00

Horseradish Crema

$3.00

Italian Dressing

$3.00

Marinara

$3.00

Ranch

$2.00

Vodka Sauce

$3.00


Drinks

Apple Juice

$3.00

Boylan's Black Cherry

$4.00

Boylan's Cola

$4.00

Boylan's Cream Soda

$4.00

Boylan's Diet Cola

$4.00

Boylan's Ginger Ale

$4.00

Boylan's Grape

$4.00

Boylan's Orange

$4.00

Homemade Lemonade

$4.00+

Saranac Root Beer

$4.00

The Pieman Pizza
  • Catering & Private Parties

  • Book a Party

  • Menu

  • Events

  • Our Story

  • We're Hiring

  • Contact Us

Terms of serviceAccessibility

The Pieman Pizza 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner