Skip to main
The Pieman Pizza
  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • APPS
  • SANDWICHES
  • PIZZA
  • SALADS
  • ENTREES
  • DESSERTS
  • KIDS
  • SAUCES
  • Soda/Juice

The Pieman Pizza Menu

107 NY-303, Valley Cottage, NY

107 NY-303, Valley Cottage, NY

·

  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • APPS
  • SANDWICHES
  • PIZZA
  • SALADS
  • ENTREES
  • DESSERTS
  • KIDS
  • SAUCES
  • Soda/Juice

Most ordered

  • PIZZA PIES.

    PIZZA PIES

    $13.00+

  • MARGHERITA 16”.

    MARGHERITA 16”

    $23.00+

  • WINGS.

    WINGS

    $14.00

  • MOZZARELLA STICKS.

    MOZZARELLA STICKS

    $13.00

  • GARLIC KNOTS.

    GARLIC KNOTS

    $8.00

  • CHOPPED CAESAR.

    CHOPPED CAESAR

    $12.00

  • POPCORN CHICKEN.

    POPCORN CHICKEN

    $14.00

  • Fried Calamari.

    Fried Calamari

    $14.00


APPS

GARLIC KNOTS

Our thin crust pizza dough tied into bowties, deep fried & tossed in garlic butter. Served w/ a pepperoni sauce.

$8.00

GARLIC KNOTS.

ONION RINGS

Housemade beer battered onion rings served w/ horsey sauce

$8.00

MEATBALLS

3 Housemade Meatballs served w/ Marinara.

$11.00

MEATBALLS.

VODKA RICEBALLS (3)

$13.00

MOZZARELLA STICKS

Housemade mozzarella sticks served w/ vodka sauce.

$13.00

MOZZARELLA STICKS.

SLIDERS

3 Sliders of your choice w/ a pickle. Cheddar Burger or Fried Chicken w/ Maple Brown Sugar Nashville Hot Sauce

$15.00

SLIDERS.

Fried Calamari

$14.00

Fried Calamari.

POPCORN CHICKEN

Deep fried chunks of chicken. Served w/ GoHo sauce (Gochujang Honey)

$14.00

POPCORN CHICKEN.

WINGS

$14.00

WINGS.

SANDWICHES

CHICKEN BALSAMICO

Seasoned Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, Arugula, Balsamic Reduction on Ciabatta

$17.00

CHICKEN BALSAMICO.

PARM SANDWICH

Choice of Chicken Cutlet, Eggplant or Housemade Meatballs w/ Marinara and Melted House Blend Cheese on Ciabatta Sub Vodka or Fra Diavlo Sauce +$1

$19.00

PARM SANDWICH.

VEGGIE VIBE

$16.00

VEGGIE VIBE.

SMASH BURGER

$16.00

PESTO CHICKEN

$18.00


PIZZA

PIZZA PIES

$13.00+

PIZZA PIES.

CALIFORNIA RANCH 16”

Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Cheddar, Avocado Crema & Chipotle Ranch.

$23.00

KOREAN WHITE HOT 16”

Fried Chicken tossed in GoHo Sauce (Gochujang Hot Honey), Ricotta, House Cheese Blend & Scallions.

$23.00

MARGHERITA 16”

Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil & Your Choose of House Marinara, Vodka or Fra Diavlo Sauce.

$23.00+

MARGHERITA 16”.

MEAT LOVERS 16”

Housemade Meatballs, Bacon, Pepperoni & DPNB Sausage

$26.00

SALTY G.O.A.T. 16”

A special blended spread of Ricotta, Goat Cheese & Honey. Topped w/ Arugula, Prosciutto, Shaved Red Onion & Drizzle of Balsamic Reduction

$23.00

SAUSAGE & SPICY PEPPERS 16”

Housemade Spicy Pickled Peppers & Heritage Pork Sausage provided by Nyack's DPNB Pasta & Provisions.

$23.00

VEGGIE SUPREME 16”

Spinach, Mushrooms, Roasted Red Peppers, White Onions & Artichoke.

$21.00

Buffalo Chicken Pizza 16”

$21.00

CHOPPED GARDEN PIE 16"

$21.00

DRUNKEN POPEYE 16'

$23.00

AUSTEN'S DELIGHT 16"

$22.00


SALADS

CHOPPED CAESAR

Romaine Lettuce, Croutons, Housemade Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parm

$12.00

CHOPPED CAESAR.

GARDEN SALAD

Mixed Greens, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Carrots, Shaved Red Onion & Housemade Italian Dressing

$10.00

GARDEN SALAD.

ITALIAN CHOPPED SALAD

Iceberg Lettuce, Roasted Red Peppers, Shaved Red Onion, Pepperoni, Prosciutto & Housemade Italian Dressing

$15.00

ITALIAN CHOPPED SALAD.

BABY SPINACH SALAD

Baby Spinach, Dried Cranberries, Granny Smith Apples, Housemade Candied Pecans, Crumbled Goat Cheese & Creamy Balsamic Dressing

$14.00

BABY SPINACH SALAD.

ENTREES

PARMIGIANA ENTREE

Your choice of Thin Italian Seasoned Chicken Cutlet or Fried Eggplant smothered in our housemade sauce & melted house cheese blend. Served over Spaghetti.

$21.00

PARMIGIANA ENTREE.

PENNE VODKA

Penne Pasta tossed Housemade Vodka Sauce. Garnished w/ Grated Parm & Fresh Basil

$16.00

PENNE VODKA.

SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS

$19.00

SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS.

PESTO PASTA CAPRESE

$18.00

SPICY BOLOGNESE

$21.00


DESSERTS

CinnaKnots

$9.00


KIDS

Kids PENNE BUTTERED PASTA

$7.00

Kids CHICKEN TENDERS

$10.00

Kids SLIDERS

$8.00

Kids SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS

$10.00


SAUCES

BLUE CHEESE

$2.00

CHIPOTLE RANCH

$3.00

HONEY MUSTARD

$2.00

HORSERADISH CREMA

$3.00

ITALIAN DRESSING

$3.00

MARINARA

$3.00

RANCH

$2.00

VODKA SAUCE

$3.00


Soda/Juice

Apple Juice

$3.00

Boylans Black Cherry

$4.00

Boylans Coke

$4.00

Boylans Cream

$4.00

Boylans Diet Coke

$4.00

Boylans Gingerale

$4.00

Boylans Grape

$4.00

Boylans Orange

$4.00

Homemade Lemonade

$4.00+

Saranac Root Beer

$4.00

The Pieman Pizza

Catering & Private Parties

Menu

Events

Our Story

We're Hiring

Contact Us

Terms of serviceAccessibility

The Pieman Pizza 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner